Should I give them my special recipe or should I let the cat out of the caserole?

Last weekend I had all of my family together at my house to celebrate the holiday and have a biig family dinner. So I went through my recipes and decided to make a tuna caserole. All during supper my family was complimenting how much they like the caserole. I can honestly say, it was really good. Well here's the deal. The next day when it was time to feed my cat, Furball, I couldn't find the cat food. I knew that I had purchased two cans of catfood while I was at the grocoery store. Then while scoping the pantry, I found two cans of catfood... I thought to myself "You dummy, you bought the cat tunafish instead... So I opened one of the cans of tuna for my kitty and as I was throwing away the can in the trash compactor I saw to cans of catfood. Bewildered, I finally realized that I had used catfood rather than tun for the caserole I made the night before. Now my family keeps asking me to make the "tuna" caserole again... Should I make it with tuna fish or with Fancy Feast?